Hockey Ghost Stories: 5 Spooky Hockey Stories

Hockey was built for ghost stories. Old barns with creaking rafters. Masked men guarding the net. Locker rooms run on superstition. A puck that bounces wrong at exactly the wrong moment, and a fanbase that needs someone to blame.

So every Halloween, the same legends come back. Here are five of hockey’s spookiest stories. First, the version fans tell in the dark. Then, the real story.

For decades, opponents walking into the Forum swore they weren’t just playing the Canadiens. They were playing every Canadien who ever lived. The legends were said to watch from the rafters, nudging pucks and tilting bounces. When the team moved out in 1996, the story says the ghosts packed up and followed them across town.

In 1937, Canadiens star Howie Morenz died, and his funeral was held at centre ice of the Forum. That image, a hockey arena turned into a chapel, helped plant the idea that Montreal’s greats never really left. What actually built the aura was 24 Stanley Cups and some of the best rosters the sport has ever seen. The ghosts are folklore, but the Canadiens still embrace them today.

In 1927, Chicago owner Frederic McLaughlin fired head coach Pete Muldoon after just one season. On his way out, Muldoon supposedly told the Black Hawks they would never finish first. And for 40 years, they didn’t.

The curse was invented. Jim Coleman, a sportswriter for The Globe and Mail, needed a column on deadline and made the whole thing up. He later admitted it. The twist: during the “curse,” Chicago still won the Stanley Cup three times. They just never finished first in the standings, until 1967.

Game 4 of the 1988 Stanley Cup Final. Bruins and Oilers, tied 3–3 in the second period. Then the old Garden goes black. Fog hanging over the ice. Fans in the dark. The game is never finished.

All true, minus anything supernatural. On May 24, 1988, a transformer blew at 16:37 of the second period and knocked out the power. The game was suspended and never replayed. Two days later, Edmonton finished the sweep at home. The fog was real too: a hot May night in an old barn with no air conditioning.

March 2011, Kings vs. Flames. A Calgary shot gets past Jonathan Quick and slides toward a wide-open net. Then it stops, changes direction and bounces away. Watch the replay. It looks like it hit a wall nobody can see.

Quick’s own explanation: he got a piece of it with his blocker, put backspin on the puck, and it caught the ice and bounced the right way. Physics, luck and soft ice. It still looks fake.

Rangers goalie Gilles Gratton believed he was a reincarnated tiger. So he painted one on his mask, snarling, teeth bared. One of the scariest masks in NHL history came straight from a past life.

The mask came from a tiger photo Gratton saw in National Geographic on a team flight. But the reincarnation part is real. Gratton openly talked about his past lives, which is how one of hockey’s great myths got started.

But that doesn’t make the stories less fun. And who knows? Maybe there’s something supernatural in all of it.

Because hockey has one kind of ghost that never goes away: the teams that disappeared.

The Quebec Nordiques became the Colorado Avalanche in 1995. The Hartford Whalers moved to Carolina in 1997. The Vancouver VooDoo vanished with Roller Hockey International. The Danbury Trashers lasted two wild seasons. And the Marquette Pirates, dating back to 1953, are still part of hockey folklore.

The teams are gone. The logos aren’t. You still see them at rinks, bars and beer-league benches, worn by fans who never let go. That’s the haunting we believe in. Shop retro and defunct hockey apparel.

Hockey has some seriously rad spooky logos. Bats, beasts, monsters and reapers, on hockey tanks, hoodies and sweaters.

Think you know your hockey legends from your hockey lies? Take the Hockey IQ Test.